Skip to stories

London 6° Edinburgh 3° Cardiff 8° Belfast 8°

Breaking

UK Politics

Burnham’s Bills Test v His EU Carbon Deal: Tories Say £230 a Year, Reform Says £150

Burnham said his EU deal must help cut electricity bills. Critics say its carbon link will cost households £112 to over £230 a year. Reform says £150.

Your vote

Should Britain keep control of its own carbon prices instead of linking them to the EU’s?

Matt · 21 Nov 2026 · 16:48 · 7 min read · 131 reads

Prime Minister Andy Burnham, left, and Staythorpe gas-fired power station in Nottinghamshire, right

0Shares

f

News | By Matt, Editor

On Monday, Andy Burnham told the City of London that any deal he signed with the EU had to make “progress on bringing down electricity bills”. On Friday he signed one that ties Britain’s carbon market to Brussels, and his critics say that will push household costs up, not down.

Tory leader Kemi Badenoch says the link will “cost households more than £230 a year”. Reform UK puts it at £150. The government has not published a figure at all.

The UK and the EU announced at their summit in Brussels that talks to link their two Emissions Trading Schemes are finished, the European Commission said. Both sides have committed to running the link from 1 January 2028, once it has been ratified. Nothing changes this winter.

1 commentTap to read
Reform UK on X, 21 November 2026, 12.47pm

What the carbon link actually does

Britain’s Emissions Trading Scheme makes power stations, factories and airlines buy a permit for every tonne of carbon dioxide they put out. Shipping is being added too. That cost ends up in the price of electricity and goods. It does not cover the gas boilers in people’s homes, the government’s explainer says.

Once the two schemes are linked, permits from either side can be used in both. The government’s explainer says that will contribute “to convergence of the carbon price”, and Britain will scrap its own minimum auction price because “it would not be practical or desirable to maintain a price floor in only one part of a linked market”.

The gap matters. A UK permit was trading at around £58 a tonne this week, against about £68 for an EU one, Energy Voice reported. The Prosperity Institute, a free-market think tank, says linking would push British carbon prices up by around 30 per cent, as they move towards the higher EU level.

What critics say it will cost you

Writing in the Daily Mail, Mrs Badenoch said: “Britain needs cheaper energy, particularly for businesses competing internationally. Yet Burnham’s reset will link Britain’s carbon-pricing with Europe’s and cost households more than £230 a year.” Conservative MP Nick Timothy has put the cost lower, at £112 a household a year, through higher prices for goods, Energy Voice says.

Nigel Farage gave Reform’s figure in a speech in Brussels on Friday. “We’re going to join the European carbon trading scheme. We estimate already that will put £150 on the gas bill of the average family home in Britain,” he said, in an extract published by Reform UK. The party has not published how it worked out the £150, and we could not find the workings.

Nigel Farage on X, 20 November 2026, 5.03pm

Richard Tice, Reform’s deputy leader, said the deal “will increase energy prices, increase regulations and damage wage prospects for young British workers”.

Richard Tice on X, 20 November 2026, 1.29pm

Burnham’s own test

Mr Burnham set the bar himself. In his speech at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet on 16 November, he said any deal had to pass three tests, the third being the “Makerfield Test”, named after his own seat: “producing real improvements in people’s everyday lives in areas of the country that have felt neglected for too long.”

He listed what that meant, including “making progress on bringing down electricity bills”. Then he added: “If the deal delivers all of this, and I believe it can, it will easily pass the Makerfield Test and I will agree it.”

Labour also promised at the 2024 election to cut bills by up to £300, and its Energy Secretary now calls the Clean Power 2030 goal a “stretch target”.

Kemi Badenoch on X, 18 November 2026, 5.24pm

Bills are already heading the wrong way. Cornwall Insight forecasts the price cap will rise 26 per cent in January to £2,166 a year for a typical home, up £443, mainly because the conflict in the Middle East has pushed up wholesale gas prices. Ofgem is due to confirm the figure on Wednesday, the Guardian reports. The carbon link is not behind that rise, but it lands on families who are already being squeezed. We covered the £443 forecast here and how the price cap works here.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham, left, and Staythorpe gas-fired power station in Nottinghamshire, right
Prime Minister Andy Burnham, left (Simon Dawson/No 10, OGL 3, Commons); Staythorpe gas-fired power station, right (Alan Murray-Rust, CC BY-SA 2.0, Commons)

The government’s case

Ministers say the link is about jobs and exports. The government’s summit explainer says it will exempt around £6.5 billion of UK exports from the EU’s new carbon border tax and add “up to £3.8 billion to the economy each year by 2040”. The government has also argued that exporters would avoid paying up to £800 million in that border tax by 2030, Energy Voice reports.

Energy UK, which speaks for energy suppliers, says a separate move to join up British and EU electricity markets could cut costs by £120 million to £370 million a year. Supporters also say a bigger carbon market gives firms steadier prices to plan around.

What the government has not done is tell families what the link means for their bills. Neither of its two explainers published on Friday mentions household bills. It says a full impact assessment will come out alongside the European Partnership Bill, and another one for the carbon link with the regulations that bring it in.

The Prosperity Institute says the £800 million figure comes from a 2024 report, and argues that scrapping the carbon taxes would save far more. Shadow Energy Secretary Andrew Bowie, endorsing its paper, said: “You cannot tax your way to prosperity.”

Reform’s answer

Reform says it would go the other way and scrap the charges altogether. At its conference in Birmingham in September, the party pledged to remove carbon charges on gas power stations, including the UK Emissions Trading Scheme and Carbon Price Support, which it said would take £90 a year off bills, Politico reported.

It would also scrap other policy costs, including what is left of the Renewables Obligation, the Feed-in Tariff and the Warm Home Discount, which helps struggling households, for another £80. It would keep VAT off electricity and take it off gas. Mr Tice said the plan would put “an extra £250 a year back into your pockets”. Those are Reform’s own figures.

Robert Jenrick, Reform’s Treasury spokesman, backing the Prosperity paper, said: “As I laid out in our Economic Rescue Plan, we’d scrap them and cut bills for families and businesses.”

Richard Tice on X, 21 November 2026, 6.31am

For more on the deal, read the Brexit reset explained, why Reynolds could not name one food that will be cheaper, and Mr Burnham’s plan for a year of talks on rejoining.

Our view

Burnham wrote his own test, and lower electricity bills were part of it. He has now signed up to a carbon link that his own government says will bring British and EU carbon prices together, at a time when EU permits cost more, and the government has not published what that will cost a family. The critics’ numbers vary, from £112 to more than £230, and Reform has not shown how it got to £150. That is exactly why the government should publish its own figure before Parliament votes, not after. A Prime Minister who says a deal will “easily pass” a bills test should be able to show the sum.

Should Britain keep control of its own carbon prices instead of linking them to the EU’s? Vote in our poll below.

Sources

  • GOV.UK: PM speech at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet, 16 November 2026
  • GOV.UK: UK-EU ETS linking agreement explainer, 20 November 2026; GOV.UK: summit explainer on ETS linking, 20 November 2026
  • European Commission: negotiations finalised to link EU and UK Emissions Trading Systems, 20 November 2026
  • Energy Voice, 20 November 2026: Kemi Badenoch (Daily Mail), Nick Timothy, carbon prices, government and Energy UK figures
  • Prosperity Institute, 17 November 2026: “Not Zero” paper, Andrew Bowie and Robert Jenrick; Prosperity Institute, 18 November 2026
  • Reform UK: Nigel Farage speech in Brussels, 20 November 2026; Politico: Reform’s £250 energy bills plan
  • Cornwall Insight, 18 November 2026: January price cap forecast; The Guardian, 18 November 2026
  • Posts on X by Reform UK, Nigel Farage, Richard Tice and Kemi Badenoch (embedded above)
  • Main image: Andy Burnham, Simon Dawson/No 10 (OGL 3); Staythorpe power station, Alan Murray-Rust (CC BY-SA 2.0), via Wikimedia Commons

Discover more from Breaking Brexit News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

0Shares

f

Have your say

What ever liebour does it will cost us more. sat in their ivory towers not one, not one of them has an understanding of how we lesser minions struggle…………now here is an idea, each MP has to stay with a family for a month, that family gets 50% of the MPs pay for that month to cover costs

Leave a Reply

Breaking Best of X Today: Tories Back Away From Reversing Burnham’s EU Deal, and Barnham Votes 257 to 16 to ‘Leave’ Read more
Next

Discover more from Breaking Brexit News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading