UK Politics
Best of X Today: Burnham’s EU Youth Scheme Leaves Us 0.0% Better Off Per Head, and the £17bn Is a 2040 Figure
The Treasury says Burnham’s EU youth scheme adds 0.0% per head, the £17bn boost is a 2040 figure, and Reform takes two Labour seats: Friday on X.
Your vote
Should the EU youth scheme be scrapped if it leaves us no better off per person?
News | By Matt, Editor
The Treasury’s own small print set X alight on Friday evening. Andy Burnham’s new EU youth scheme would grow the economy and the population by about the same amount, so the gain for each of us comes to 0.0%.
Burnham agreed his deal in Brussels on Friday. Earlier today we covered the youth scheme of up to 100,000 a year, the EU’s demand on tuition fees, Jonathan Reynolds failing to name one food that will be cheaper and Nigel Farage’s reply in Brussels. Here are the day’s best posts, and what the record shows behind each one. Last night’s round-up is here.

1. Tom Harwood: the 0.0% line in the small print
GB News’s Tom Harwood spotted it first. In a note published at 1.09pm, HM Treasury says the youth scheme “increases both GDP and the population (through higher net migration) by similar proportions, so the impact on GDP per capita is 0.0% at one decimal place” (HM Treasury).
Have your sayTap to commentThe same note expects the scheme to add 18,000 to 43,000 to net migration in its first year and up to 50,000 in its third, before it settles at 8,000 to 14,000 a year. The scheme is capped at 100,000 arrivals a year, aged 18 to 31, and starts in 2030. Nigel Farage’s reply, that Burnham’s own analysis means “MORE migration but NO growth in incomes”, drew more than 1,300 likes. To be precise, the 0.0% is for the youth scheme, not the food and carbon deals.
2. The Cabinet Office’s £17bn, and the date it left out
The Cabinet Office told its followers the deal was “a £17 billion boost for the British economy”. More than 500 people replied. Only about 70 liked it.
The government’s own release says the deals “could add up to 0.5% to UK GDP by 2040 – equivalent to around £17 billion a year” (No 10). Andrew Neil, whose reply drew more than 2,300 likes, called it a “fantasy” figure and pointed out the post didn’t say it was “£17bn by 2040”. Food and drink account for up to £5.1bn of it, and linking carbon markets up to £3.8bn. Up to 0.2% of GDP, about two-fifths of the headline, comes from the youth scheme: the part the Treasury says adds nothing per head.
3. Braverman: one million young Brits out of work or training
Suella Braverman says Burnham has “completely betrayed our young people” by “letting in 100,000 young Europeans to study and work here” while “1 million young Brits can’t get a job or training opportunity”. Her post drew more than 1,300 likes.
Burnham raised the same figure himself in his summit speech, pointing to “the one million young people in our country, not in education, employment and training” (GOV.UK). The youth scheme needs no job offer and has no language or salary test. Those who come pay a £340 visa fee and the health surcharge, and cannot claim benefits or bring dependants (HM Treasury).
4. Jenrick: £450m on EU students
Robert Jenrick’s post, with more than 1,100 likes, mocked “another 100,000 migrants from Europe” and “£450 million sending EU students to British universities”.
The £450m is the yearly sum ministers were reported to be ready to spend on cheaper fees for EU students (Guardian, Telegraph), which we reported on 7 November. Friday’s deal set no fee. Both sides gave themselves until May 2027 to agree one, and EU countries say they will not adopt the youth, food and carbon deals until that is done (Politico). On Friday evening Sky News pressed minister Hamish Falconer on why it couldn’t be settled now. The 100,000 is the yearly cap; the Treasury expects the net rise to be lower.
5. Badenoch: “a distraction”
Kemi Badenoch said in a video on Friday evening that Burnham’s deal “is a distraction” and “doesn’t solve any of the problems Britain is facing”. It came a day after Brussels told Britain to rejoin or take all its rules.
6. Reform UK: two more seats taken from Labour
While Burnham was in Brussels, Reform UK was counting votes at home. It took Risca East from Labour with 438 votes to Labour’s 285, its first seat on Caerphilly council (Caerphilly Observer), and Huntington and Hatherton in South Staffordshire with 53% (ConservativeHome).
It held Craghead and South Moor in Durham by 820 votes to 728 (Durham County Council), keeping its majority on the council (BBC). Reform won three of the nine contests on the night and came second in Rotherham by 45 votes.
7. Lee Anderson: standing again in Ashfield
Lee Anderson’s news that Ashfield Reform UK has picked him again for the next general election drew more than 3,000 likes, one of the biggest posts of the day by a Reform MP.
In July 2024 he won Ashfield for Reform with 17,062 votes, 42.8% and a majority of 5,508, up from the 39.3% he won as a Conservative in 2019 (UK Parliament).
Our view
Burnham sold this deal on one number, £17bn. The Treasury’s own note shows about two-fifths of it comes from more people, not richer people, and the full figure isn’t due until 2040. Families were told this deal would cut costs and keep prices down. On the government’s own sums, the youth scheme leaves each of us no better off.
Should the EU youth scheme be scrapped if it leaves us no better off per person? Vote in our poll below.
Sources
- HM Treasury methodology note on the Youth Experience Scheme (20 Nov)
- No 10 press release; Prime Minister’s summit speech (20 Nov)
- Guardian, Telegraph (£450m, 1 Nov); Politico (tuition fees link)
- Caerphilly Observer; ConservativeHome; Durham County Council; BBC (by-elections)
- UK Parliament election results (Ashfield)
- Posts on X, embedded or linked above
- Main image: Simon Dawson / No 10 (OGL 3) and Robert Lamb (CC BY-SA 2.0), via Wikimedia Commons, cropped
Discover more from Breaking Brexit News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Have your say