Skip to stories

London 10° Edinburgh 4° Cardiff 9° Belfast 7°

Breaking

UK Politics

Only 2,227 of 24,600 Homes Botched Under Government Insulation Schemes Have Been Fixed, Minister Admits

Repairs are done at just 2,227 of 24,600 homes left with faulty wall insulation under schemes paid for on our energy bills, a Labour minister has admitted.

Your vote

Should the firms that botched government insulation be made to pay for the repairs?

Matt · 20 Nov 2026 · 10:24 · 6 min read · 77 reads

Energy minister Martin McCluskey alongside black mould on a wall

0Shares

f

News | By Matt, Editor

Repairs have been finished at just 2,227 of the 24,600 homes left with faulty wall insulation under two government energy schemes, a Labour minister has admitted. That means more than nine in ten households are still waiting for the botched work to be put right (BBC).

Energy minister Martin McCluskey gave the figure to the Commons Energy Security and Net Zero Committee on Wednesday. He told MPs he was shocked by the scale of the failures and that the schemes “didn’t have correct oversight”.

The schemes were not paid for by the taxman. They were paid for by you. The National Audit Office says the Energy Company Obligation, which funded the work, “is funded from consumer bills” (NAO).

Have your sayTap to comment
Energy minister Martin McCluskey alongside black mould on a wall
Energy minister Martin McCluskey (UK Government, CC BY 4.0, Commons) and mould on a wall, illustration (Shai Avidan, CC BY-SA 4.0, Commons)

What went wrong

The trouble lies in two schemes: ECO4, launched in 2022, and the Great British Insulation Scheme, which opened in 2023 and has now closed. More than 300,000 homes have had heat pumps, solar panels and insulation fitted under the £4bn ECO4 scheme, which closes in December, according to the BBC.

Energy suppliers were told to pay for the work and recover the cost from customers. The firms on the ground were meant to be checked. They were not checked properly. When the government finally audited the external wall insulation, it found that almost every home had defects that needed fixing.

The National Audit Office put it at 98% of homes with external wall insulation, between 22,000 and 23,000 households, with major problems. Most of those faults stop the insulation working as it should, often creating a risk of water getting in and mould. Six per cent posed health and safety risks that needed fixing at once, such as poor ventilation (NAO).

Internal wall insulation was not much better. Around 29% of those homes, between 9,000 and 13,000, also had major issues. Fixing each external wall job should cost between £5,000 and £18,000 if it is caught before serious damage sets in, the watchdog said.

BBC News on X, 19 November 2026, 6.39pm

Two years of waiting

The poor work was flagged in audits in October 2024, a few months after Labour came to power (BBC). Two years on, fewer than one home in ten has had the repairs finished.

Ken Palfrey, a 66-year-old retired builder from Birmingham, had external wall insulation fitted through ECO in 2024. He told the BBC it was “botched”, damaging his window sills and leaving damp and mould on his walls. After months of complaints an inspection found it had been fitted wrongly and he was told it had to come off immediately.

He says he has spent two years on a “merry-go-round”, “hundreds and hundreds of hours writing emails and complaining to people”. “It’s been an absolute nightmare,” he said. “Every day of my life, every time you look at the insulation, you’re worried about it.”

TrustMark, the government-backed quality scheme, said it was sorry for what he had been through and has referred him to the National Energy Foundation, a charity that fixes homes where the installer has gone bust.

BBC political reporter Joshua Nevett on X, 19 November 2026, 4.26pm

Everyone blames someone else

Asked by MPs whether he had confidence in Ofgem, the energy regulator that oversees the schemes, Mr McCluskey did not answer directly. “There’s clearly been failures in the system. We’re designing a system now,” he said.

Ofgem, for its part, says the quality of the work was never its job. “It is unacceptable that households have been left with substandard ECO4 work. Ofgem was not responsible for assuring the quality of installations,” a spokesperson said, adding that the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero “is responsible for the design and overall outcomes of ECO”.

The department says it “inherited the failing ECO4 scheme”, which began under the Conservatives in 2022, and has ended it. “No household should have to pay to put the issues right,” a spokesperson said. “Our Warm Homes Plan will overhaul the system to protect consumers and ensure failings are not repeated.”

MPs have heard all this before. In January the Commons Public Accounts Committee called the failures “catastrophic” and said this was the worst rate of failure it had seen in its chair’s twelve or so years on the committee (Public Accounts Committee). A follow-up letter from the committee to the department’s most senior civil servant says an update promised for June 2026 was not provided on time, and that when the department’s update came in October it did not say how many homes had actually been fixed (committee letter).

Commons Public Accounts Committee on X, 23 January 2026

Fraud on top

Botched work is only part of it. In November 2024 Ofgem estimated that firms had falsified claims for between 5,600 and 16,500 homes, potentially claiming between £56m and £165m from energy suppliers, and so, in the end, from billpayers (Independent, NAO).

In April, GB News reported that four people had been arrested in a £44m home insulation fraud investigation.

GB News on X, 22 April 2026

Campaigners say the true number of damaged homes is far higher. Fuel Poverty Action believes faults under a range of government schemes could affect as many as 100,000 homes. Its policy lead, Jonathan Bean, said ignoring other defective work “is shockingly negligent, and is causing huge harm”, and called faulty internal wall insulation “a ticking time bomb in homes” (BBC).

Fuel Poverty Action on X, 16 June 2026

Households who think they are affected can check the government’s guidance on faulty wall insulation.

The bill keeps coming

All this lands as energy bills are forecast to jump by £443 in January, and as Labour’s energy plans pile more costs and rules on homes, from the standing charge shake-up to fines of up to £30,000 for landlords who miss new energy ratings. Labour’s Energy Bill could even open your HMRC tax records to energy firms.

Our view

This was a Net Zero scheme sold as a way to cut bills for poorer families. Instead thousands of them got damp, mould and two years of chasing emails, and everyone else paid for it through their own bills. The Tories built the scheme, but Labour has had two years since the faults were found and has fixed fewer than one home in ten. Ofgem blames the department, the department blames the last government, and the minister is “designing a system now”. Before ministers spend another penny of our money on their Net Zero plans, they should fix what they have already broken, and make the cowboys pay for it.

Should the firms that botched government insulation be made to pay for the repairs? Vote in our poll below.

Sources

  • BBC (19 Nov: minister’s evidence, 2,227 of 24,600, Ofgem, DESNZ, TrustMark, Ken Palfrey, Fuel Poverty Action)
  • National Audit Office press release and report (October 2025: funded from consumer bills, 98%, 29%, repair costs, falsified claims)
  • Independent (falsified claims “ultimately from billpayers”); Public Accounts Committee report and letter
  • Posts on X by BBC News, Joshua Nevett, the Public Accounts Committee, GB News and Fuel Poverty Action (embedded above)
  • Main image: UK Government (CC BY 4.0) and Shai Avidan (CC BY-SA 4.0), via Wikimedia Commons

Discover more from Breaking Brexit News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

0Shares

f

Have your say

Leave a Reply

Breaking Farage: ‘Naive’ Burnham ‘Strong-Armed’ Over EU Student Fees Read more
Next

Discover more from Breaking Brexit News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading