UK Politics
Benefits Bill Up £50bn, About £1,200 per Taxpayer, and Labour’s Fix Could Take 10 Years to Pay Off
Working-age benefits now cost almost £140bn a year, up £50bn since 2019 or about £1,200 per taxpayer, and Labour’s fix could take 10 years to save money.
Your vote
Should Labour cut the working-age benefits bill now, not in 10 years?
News | By Matt, Editor
Britain now spends almost £140 billion a year on working-age benefits, £50 billion more than in 2019 once inflation is taken out. The Centre for Social Justice puts the rise at around £1,200 for every taxpayer.
And the fix? Whitehall sources have admitted Labour’s welfare plans could take as long as 10 years to deliver any savings, GB News reports, citing the Daily Mail.
The figures, set out again in the Telegraph this morning, show 6.7 million people now get at least one out-of-work benefit. That’s one working-age adult in six. In 2019 it was 3.9 million.
1 commentTap to readIncapacity claims up 61%, disability up 16%
The biggest driver is sickness. According to the CSJ, the number of people on incapacity benefits has jumped by 61% since 2019, while the share of working-age people reporting a disability rose by 16%. The Telegraph calls Britain an “international outlier”.
The think tank, founded by Sir Iain Duncan Smith, also counts almost 1.7 million more working-age claimants who face no requirement at all to look for work or prepare for it. That’s 1.7 million people the system has stopped asking anything of.
Then there’s the trap. The CSJ says a single claimant who isn’t working and gets the Universal Credit health element and housing support plus PIP can receive around £27,400 a year, tax-free. Someone on the National Living Wage would have to earn more than £33,000 to take home the same, which means working more than 50 hours, six days a week. The government has since cut the health element for most new claims, which brings the package down to about £24,800, but that doesn’t touch the more than three million people already on it, the CSJ says.
Its State of Dependency report found 3,369 neighbourhoods in England and Wales where most working-age adults are on out-of-work benefits. Blackpool, Hartlepool and Redcar and Cleveland top the list.
In Liverpool around 22% of neighbourhoods have out-of-work claimants equal to at least 40% of working-age adults, the report found. In Birmingham it’s 18%. In London, just 2%. Mental health is a big part of it: 3.2 million more working-age people report a mental health difficulty than in 2012.
British workers got one in five of 3.7m new jobs, CSJ says
The CSJ links the welfare bill to migration policy too. Of the 3.7 million extra payroll jobs created since 2014, it says, British nationals took around one in five. Over the same years the number of people on out-of-work benefits, mostly British, rose by 2.3 million. In the think tank’s words, employers gained “unprecedented access to overseas labour while taxpayers have absorbed the growing cost of domestic worklessness”.
It also says the state spent £1.6 trillion on working-age benefits over the last two decades. That’s more than £1.1 trillion more than it put into transport, science and technology, and housing combined.
Sir Iain Duncan Smith put it bluntly on GB News this week: “If you give them too many incentives to stay in welfare, they won’t go to work. So you have to make it tough love.”
“Kicking the can down the road”
Andy Burnham has been accused of exactly that. Alan Milburn’s review of youth worklessness lands next week, and it is expected to urge the Prime Minister to stop under-25s claiming the health element of Universal Credit and PIP, with the money moved into back-to-work schemes.
Burnham called it a “watershed moment”. But at the European Political Community summit in Dublin he didn’t dispute the 10-year timescale, GB News reports. He said his plans wouldn’t involve “more money” and that the upfront costs would be found “elsewhere in Government”. Asked to commit to the review’s recommendations, he said: “I can’t give you that blanket assurance here tonight.”
In the meantime the overall welfare bill, pensions included, is forecast to climb from £333.8 billion to £431.3 billion by the end of 2030. Health and disability payments alone are expected to go from £85.6 billion to £120.2 billion.
Robert Jenrick, Reform UK’s Treasury spokesman, told the Daily Mail: “No amount of reviews will change the Labour Party’s addiction to benefits. This is yet another can-kicking exercise, with taxpayers made to fork out billions more in taxes to pay for Burnham’s weakness.”
Kemi Badenoch went further on X, posting: “When I tell people Labour are the Welfare Party….”
The other side
Not everyone in Labour wants any cuts at all. Labour MP Brian Leishman told the Mail: “Taking money off young disabled people who cannot work will not incentivise anyone into work.” Backbenchers warn the plans would create a “two-tier” welfare system, and the Telegraph reports a Left-wing revolt is brewing.
Milburn himself frames it as help, not a cut. He wants a legal guarantee that every young person gets a job, training or support, BBC Politics reports, with people with severe disabilities protected.
It’s also fair to say the rise didn’t start in July 2024. Much of the £50 billion built up under the Conservatives after Covid. But Labour has been in charge for more than two years, and the bill is still going up.
What happens next
Milburn’s full review is due to be published next week, and Burnham says the government will “set out our response next week” too. Expect a fight. Labour’s last attempt at welfare savings, under Keir Starmer, was gutted by a backbench rebellion in 2025, when the PIP changes were dropped, and many of the same MPs are lining up again. Every month the row drags on, the bill keeps rising, and it’s working taxpayers who cover it.
It comes days after the OBR’s own database showed Labour’s tax rises will take £85bn a year by 2031-32. This morning we reported that Burnham is looking at PIP for every working age, not just the under-25s. And on Friday a court heard about a serial burglar on £45,000 a year in benefits.
Our view: £50 billion more, every year, and the people paying it are being told to wait up to a decade for a saving. Workers on £33,000 are funding packages worth just as much to people who aren’t asked to look for a job. That isn’t compassion, it’s a broken deal. Labour has the biggest majority in a generation. If it can’t fix this now, when will it?
Should Labour cut the working-age benefits bill now, not in 10 years? Vote below.
Sources
- The Telegraph, 14 November 2026: £50bn rise, £1,200 per taxpayer, 6.7m on out-of-work benefits, 61% v 16%
- Centre for Social Justice, State of Dependency: £140bn, £27,400 v £33,000, 1.7m with no work requirements
- GB News, 14 November 2026: Up to 10 years for savings (Daily Mail), Burnham, Jenrick and Leishman quotes, forecasts
- The Telegraph, 11 October 2026: 3,369 welfare hotspots, city figures, mental health
- The Telegraph, 13 October 2026: CSJ payroll jobs analysis
- BBC Politics on X, 14 November 2026: Milburn job guarantee
Main image: Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden at Lancaster House, London (UK Government / FCDO, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons); Jobcentre Plus, Park Place, Leeds (Mtaylor848, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons).
Discover more from Breaking Brexit News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Have your say
Your reaction
as usual the uni party rack up the debts and expect the tax payer to pay it…. they are not governing they are giving our wealth away.. traitorous every one of them